Skip to main content

Demerits of the Parliamentary system

The parliamentary system of government has the following demerits.

1. Unstable government.
2. No continuity of policies.
3. Dictatorship of the cabinet.
4. Against separation of powers.
5. Government by amateurs.



Unstable government
the Parliament system does not provide a stable government. there is no guarantee that the government can survive its tenure. the ministers depend on the mercy of the majority legislators for their continuity and survival in office. a no-confidence motion or political defection or evils of multiparty coalition can make the government unstable. the government headed by Morarji Desai, Charan Singh, VP Singh, Chandra shekhar, Dev Goda and I K Gujral are some such examples.

No continuity of policies
the parliamentary system is not conducted for the formulation and implementation of Long Term Policies. this is due to the uncertainty of the tenure of the government. a change in the ruling party is usually followed by changes in the policy of the government. for example, the Janata government headed by Morarji Desai in 1977 reversed a large number of policies of the previous Congress government. the same was repeated by the Congress government after it came back to power in 1980.

Dictatorship of the cabinet
when the ruling party enjoy the absolute majority in the Parliament, the cabinet become autocratic and exercises nearly unlimited powers.
H.J ladki says that the parliamentary system gives the executive an opportunity for Tyranny. Ramsay muir the former British Prime Minister, also complained of the 'dictatorship of the cabinet' this phenomena was witnessed during the era of the Indira Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi.

Against separation of powers
in the parliamentary system the legislature and executive are together and inseparable. the cabinet acts as the leader of Legislature as well as the executive.
As Bagehot points out, 'the cabinet is a hyphen that joins the buckle that binds the executive and legislative department together. 'hence the whole system of the government goes against the letter and spirit of the theory of separation of powers. in fact, there is a fusion of powers.

Government by Amateurs
the parliamentary system is not conducive to administrative efficiency as the ministers are not expert in their fields. the prime minister has a limited choice in the selection of ministers, his choice is restricted to the members of parliament alone and does not extend to external talent. moreover, the Prime Minister devote most of their time in parliamentary work, cabinet meetings and party activities.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Features of the federal system in India

The federal features of the constitution of india are explained below. 1. Dual polity. 2. Written constitution. 3. Division of powers. 4. Supremacy of the constitution. 5. Rigid constitution. 6. Independent judiciary. 7. Bicameralism. Dual polity The constitution establishes a dual polity consisting the Union at the centre and state at the Periphery. each is endowed with Sovereign power to be exercised in the field assigned to them respectively by the constitution. the union government deals with the matters of national importance like defence, Foreign Affairs, currency, communication and so on. the state governments on the other hand look after the matters of regional and local importance like public order, agriculture, health, local government and so on. Written constitution The constitution is not only a written document but also the lengthiest constitution of the world. originally, it contained a Preamble, 395 articles divided into 22 parts and 8 schedules. at

Features of the Parliamentary Government

The parliamentary government is a type of democratic government, in which the government governs the nation from the parliament. The following features of the Parliament government. 1. Nominal and real executives. 2. Majority party rule. 3. Political homogeneity. 4. Collective responsibility. 5. Double membership. 6. Leadership of the Prime minister. 7. Dissolution of the Lower house. 8. Secrecy. Nominal and real executives. It is the first feature of the parliamentary government in which the president is the nominal executive executive. ( de jure executive or the titural executive ), while the Prime Minister is the real executive ( de facto executive ). Thus the president is head of the state, while the prime minister is head of the government, according to the Constitution of india (article-74) provides for a Council of Ministers headed by the prime minister, to aid and advise the president in the exercise of his functions. The advise so tendered is binding on the